Let us create a 3D eBook for you!
Let us create a 3d Digital eBook for you! DigyCat.com

 

The Potential Conundrum of Regulating Pay-TV


In last week's column, I argued the merits (or rather the lack thereof) of extending decency regulations to cable and satellite TV. This week, I'll point out just how much of a quagmire this would actually be and how difficult it would be to implement, regardless of the merits.

Regulating cable and satellite TV would not be as clear-cut as it might seem on the surface. Remember, we are talking about the regulation of indecency which, unlike obscenity, is protected by the First Amendment. The complexities of such an undertaking are quite formidable, to say the least. There are several key issues that would have to be dealt with and overcome. Like they say, the devil is in the details.

For one thing, Congress would need to determine the scope of what is to be regulated. Would it be cable and satellite TV only or all forms of pay-TV?

If Congress sets out to regulate all forms of pay-TV, the term - "pay-TV" - would have to be legally defined. Besides satellite and cable, would it also include the new IPTV technology in which TV channels, programs, and movies are delivered to TV set-top boxes from the internet? Would internet video viewed on a computer also be included? Or would everything originating from the internet be automatically exempt?

Would wireless pay TV services also be included?

Would videos, whether rented or purchased, also be defined as a form of pay-TV? One could make a case for them being included because videos, both VHS and DVD, are ultimately played on a TV.

What about video delivered by cell phone? Couldn't that also be considered a form of pay-TV?

Now, if Congress decides that the new regulations will only apply to cable and satellite TV, there are still problems. Would all channels on every cable and satellite TV system be regulated or would the regulations just apply to the so-called "basic" channels. Would the term, "all channels", include pay-per-view and video-on-demand (VOD) programs and movies? If so, how would the safe-harbor hours be enforced with VOD, since the subscriber determines when the programs and movies play?

If only the basics are to be included, some definition would be have to be devised to determine the difference between a basic and a premium channel. Would any channel that could be purchased as part of a package of channels be defined as a basic channel? If so, then most channels we currently think of as premiums would be included because they can be packaged together with similar channels. For example, HBO is sometimes packaged with channels like Cinemax, Showtime, Starz, or even other multiplexes of HBO.

Or would basics be limited those channels available in the first tier or two? Since this packaging varies from one cable and satellite system to the next, how would anyone know which channels are the real basics? Would premiums be limited to channels that could be subscribed to individually at an additional price? If that's the case, would a multiplex channel like HBO Signature will treated like a basic, since it cannot be subscribed to individually? Also, the channels that one can subscribe to individually vary slightly from one cable and satellite system to the next, so how would anyone know which channels are the real premiums? When things like that differ from one cable and satellite system to another, would the rules be based on how the majority of the systems operate? Or would some other method be used to resolve this matter?

Perhaps the presence or absence of commercials could be used to separate the basics from the premiums. Under that system, all channels that are advertiser-supported would be considered basics and those that are not would be considered premiums. However, there are potential problems with this methodology as well. Congress would have to come up with a definition for advertiser-supported. Would it be based on the amount of advertising a channel carries? If so, how much advertising would it have to carry to be legally considered advertiser-supported? Or perhaps it would be based on the amount of revenue a channel derives from advertising. If so, what would that threshold be?

Even the term, "advertising", would have to be legally defined. Would product placement found in movies and TV shows be included in the advertising equation? What about promos run for shows on related channels? Would those count as ads?

Even when all of that is sorted out, this methodology still leaves us with the problem presented by channels like Turner Classic Movies, Fox Movie Channel, and the Independent Film Channel, which don't carry commercials but are included in many basic packages.

Now, assuming that all of the issues surrounding the scope of the new regulations could be worked out, the penalty issues would then have to be resolved. Who would pay the fines? Channel owners? Cable and satellite operators? Performers? All of them?

If internet audio and video are included in the scope of the regulations, would internet service providers and/or IPTV operators also have to pay?

If cable and satellite operators have to pay, couldn't large fines potentially limit some smaller cable companies' ability to expand and implement new technology like high-definition channels?

Then there's the issue of license revocation. Cable and satellite channels don't have licenses like broadcast channels. How could a habitual offender's license be revoked if it doesn't have license to begin with? Or would it just be put out of business? But wouldn't that limit the channel choices available to cable and satellite customers?

Could cable and satellite operators be put out of business? Wouldn't that leave people in some areas with no cable franchise? Wouldn't it squash competition for cable service in areas that currently have it? Would the FCC actually shut down Directv and/or Dish Network and render thousands of backyard dishes worthless?

As you can see, there is a mountain of complicated questions that would have to be answered before the decency regulation of pay-TV could become a reality. Obviously, there would be lots of i's to dot and t's to cross. As this legislation is being considered, lawyers throughout the Capital area are already licking their chops!

Terry Mitchell is a software engineer, freelance writer, and trivia buff from Hopewell, VA. He also serves as a political columnist for American Daily and operates his own website - http://www.commenterry.com - on which he posts commentaries on various subjects such as politics, technology, religion, health and well-being, personal finance, and sports. His commentaries offer a unique point of view that is not often found in mainstream media.


MORE RESOURCES:

Satellite TV - Google News

SES-4 Satellite Launch Re-Scheduled for February 14-15 - Business Wire (press release)


SES-4 Satellite Launch Re-Scheduled for February 14-15
Business Wire (press release)
LUXEMBOURG--(BUSINESS WIRE)--SES SA (Paris:SESG)(LuxX:SESG) announces that ILS has re-scheduled the SES-4 satellite launch from the Baikonur Cosmodrome on board an ILS Proton Breeze M rocket for 1:36 am local time on February 15 th , 2012 (February 14 ...

Satellite Beach to review City Manager Michael Crotty's employment contract - Florida Today


Satellite Beach to review City Manager Michael Crotty's employment contract
Florida Today
File photo shows Satellite Beach City Manager Michael Crotty greeting people after a meeting. Crotty earns $126059 per year as Satellite Beach's chief executive officer. He has served since September 2, 1985, overseeing City Hall services for this ...

Digi Extends Internet of AnyThing to Iridium Satellite Network - MarketWatch (press release)


Digi Extends Internet of AnyThing to Iridium Satellite Network
MarketWatch (press release)
MINNETONKA, Minn., Feb 07, 2012 (BUSINESS WIRE) -- Digi International /quotes/zigman/71053/quotes/nls/dgii DGII -0.34% today announced that the Iridium satellite network now supports the iDigi Device Cloud(TM). Similar to cellular SMS, Digi devices ...

and more »

Satellite industry growth to continue despite challenges - Telecompaper (subscription)


Satellite industry growth to continue despite challenges
Telecompaper (subscription)
Prospects for the satellite industry will remain favourable over the decade in a variety of areas, according to Euroconsult studies. The next ten years should see continued growth for commercial markets, while at the same time stagnating growth for ...
Satellite Industry Growth To Continue Despite Challenging EnvironmentDirectionsMag.com (press release)
Euroconsult's Long-Term Satellite Forecast Bullish on Commercial, Bearish on ...Satellite Today (subscription)

all 4 news articles »

Satellite study reveals critical habitat and corridors for world's rarest gorilla - Space Ref (press release)


Satellite study reveals critical habitat and corridors for world's rarest gorilla
Space Ref (press release)
The newly published habitat analysis, which used a combination of satellite imagery and on-the-ground survey work, will help guide future management decisions for Cross River gorillas living in the mountainous border region between Nigeria and Cameroon ...

and more »

ViaSat Versus Space Systems/Loral... Infringement Inferred (Business) - SatNews Publishers


SatNews Publishers

ViaSat Versus Space Systems/Loral... Infringement Inferred (Business)
SatNews Publishers
[SatNews] Peter B.de Selding in Space News reports that satellite broadband provider ViaSat Inc. has filed a patent infringement lawsuit in a California court against satellite builder Space Systems/Loral (SS/L).... Artistic rendition of the ViaSat-1 ...
Suing Space Systems/Loral Costing ViaSat $1 Million per QuarterSpace News
VIASAT'S EARNINGS HIT MARK; REVENUE MISSESU-T San Diego
ViaSat Q3 Profit Declines - UpdateNASDAQ
Advanced Television
all 7 news articles »

SB112 aims to level cable, satellite television tax rates - Deseret News


SB112 aims to level cable, satellite television tax rates
Deseret News
By Marjorie Cortez, Deseret News SALT LAKE CITY — Tax policy shouldn't determine the winner and losers in the cable or satellite marketplace, says Sen. Wayne Neiderhauser, whose attempt to evenly tax the competing television services prompted a flurry ...
Senator wants to level taxes between cable, satellite customersDaily Herald
Utah Legislature: Cable customers could get small breakSalt Lake Tribune

all 5 news articles »

Iran Reports Launch of Small Satellite - Sci-Tech Today


Sci-Tech Today

Iran Reports Launch of Small Satellite
Sci-Tech Today
By Nasser Karimi Iran's Navid satellite was sent into orbit by a missile launch-vehicle dubbed Safir. Navid is designed to collect data on weather conditions and monitor for natural disasters. But Iran's decade-old space program has raised alarms in ...
Iran reports launching small satellite into orbit, latest in its ambitious ...Washington Post
Iran Lifts Off Satellite 'Navid' Into OrbitFrench Tribune
Iran reports launch of small satellite into orbitDAWN.com
Huffington Post
all 314 news articles »

How NASA Makes Those Incredible High-Res Images of Earth - Wired News


Wired News

How NASA Makes Those Incredible High-Res Images of Earth
Wired News
Taken by the Suomi NPP satellite, these pictures portray our planet's incredible beauty with 8000- by 8000-pixel and 11500- by 11500-pixel detail. How were these highly detailed images created? The satellite flies 512 miles above the Earth, ...
The Blue Marble 2012, an Incredible Image of the Pale Blue DotUnion of Concerned Scientists (blog)
Blue Marble By Suomi NPPSpace Daily
"Blue Marble' view of Earth's other sideCBS News
Discovery News -French Tribune -The State Column
all 89 news articles »

NASA NASA Seeks Smaller, Better Satellites - InformationWeek


NASA NASA Seeks Smaller, Better Satellites
InformationWeek
Agency puts out call for flight demos of small satellites that can do more, while being launched more quickly and more cheaply, to provide new opportunities for space research and communications. By Elizabeth Montalbano InformationWeek NASA is seeking ...
NASA Wants Small-satellite Demo ProposalsAviation Week
NASA looks for small satellite swarming technologyFierceGovernmentIT
NASA Seeks Small Satellite SolutionsSignal Magazine

all 4 news articles »

Click here for Best Buy In-Store Pickup

StreetSideAuto.com

Looking For Royalty Free Photos for your Website, Business or Advertising?

My Life Through The Lens

YourFree.biz Domain Is For Sale - $5,000 For Enquiries eMail Us

© www.YourFree.biz 2011

home | site map | links

eXTReMe Tracker